Should you choose Thaw or Tuck?
Choose Thaw if you want a free, open-source manager with a large feature set and are on macOS 26, or are happy to run its macOS 27 beta. Choose Tuck if you need one stable release that covers macOS 14 through 27, want a small tool with a Shelf for notched MacBooks, and are happy to pay once for Pro rather than use a free app.
What Thaw publishes about itself
- License and price: Thaw's repository lists GPL-3.0 and says it is free, with no subscription, no account and no tracking.
- Maintenance: The repository was pushed to on 2026-11-04. Its releases page shows stable 2.1.0 (2026-10-14) and the pre-release 3.0.0-beta.5 (2026-11-02). A 3.0.0-beta.6 tag exists (2026-11-03), but we found no published release notes for it.
- macOS support: The README lists Thaw 2 for macOS 15–26 and Thaw 3 for macOS 27. Thaw 3 is still in beta: the 3.0.0-beta.5 notes are labeled "macOS 27 only", so the line that supports macOS 27 is not a stable release yet.
- Recent beta changes: The 3.0.0-beta.5 notes add a Settings button that takes new pictures of Hidden and Always Hidden items on request, and say Thaw no longer moves the pointer with a simulated mouse drag when it reorders items.
- Features it describes: The release notes and README mention a layout editor, the Thaw Bar, settings profiles, triggers and a
thaw://automation layer.
Thaw grew out of Ice. Compare its project pages with your needs rather than relying on a static feature list here.
Where Tuck differs
Tuck organizes a crowded status area with one-click Push Mode, a Shelf Mode panel for hidden icons, and per-icon control. It does not try to match Thaw feature for feature. Tuck 1.5.6 is a single stable release for macOS 14–27, and the macOS app sends no telemetry or analytics (the usetuck.com website has its own opt-in analytics, covered in the privacy policy). Its expected network use is license validation and update checks; see the privacy policy.
One release, macOS 14–27
The same stable download covers Sonoma through Golden Gate. See the macOS 27 guide.
Shelf for the notch
Hidden icons appear in a panel below the bar. See the MacBook notch guide.
Pay once, or stay free
The free tier has no time limit. Pro is US$14.99 one-time for up to three Macs, with no subscription.
Tuck Pro is sold through Dodo Payments, the Merchant of Record. Quartz develops Tuck and licenses it. See the terms for the current details.
Who should pick which?
Thaw fits you if you run macOS 15–26 (or accept a beta on macOS 27), want the free and open-source route, and like a deep settings surface. It is the sensible default if cost is the main concern, and it needs no purchase at all.
Tuck fits you if you are on macOS 14 or 27 as well as 15–26, want a stable release rather than a pre-release for macOS 27, or prefer a simpler workflow with a Shelf. Pro adds automation and Shelf customization, and you can test the free tier first. Check the macOS 27 status table for every app's current position.
Frequently asked questions
Is Thaw free?
Thaw's repository says it is free, with no subscription, no account and no tracking, under GPL-3.0 (checked 2026-11-04). Tuck also has a free tier with no time limit; Pro is US$14.99 one-time.
Does Thaw support macOS 27?
Its README lists Thaw 3 for macOS 27, and the 3.0.0-beta.5 release notes (2026-11-02) are labeled macOS 27 only. Thaw 3 is a pre-release; stable 2.1.0 (2026-10-14) is the latest non-beta release and is not listed for macOS 27. Tuck 1.5.6 is a stable release that supports macOS 27.
Is Thaw the same as Ice?
No. Thaw is a separate, actively developed project that grew out of Ice. Ice's own latest stable release we found is 0.11.12 from October 2024; see the Ice alternative page.
Can I use Tuck on macOS 14 or 15?
Yes. Tuck 1.5.6 supports macOS 14–27 in one download. Thaw's README lists Thaw 2 for macOS 15–26 and Thaw 3 for macOS 27, so macOS 14 is not listed there.
Source note
Thaw statements come from its official repository and release notes, read on 2026-11-04 (the beta.6 tag was seen on the same day). We have not tested Thaw ourselves. Tuck statements follow the current terms, privacy policy and signed release feeds. Quartz makes Tuck, so read this page with that interest in mind; see the methodology. Vendor pages change, so open the linked source before you decide.